
It's January 2 2009. I'm a few days late with this -- no excuse really. But I know you've all been waiting for my first annual best and worst movies list for 2008. Oh sure, many periodicals with somewhat larger readership weigh in on this topic, and many of them see every movie (not me), but no lists generate as much buzz among my 7 readers as this one.
So -- even though I haven't seen the Hannah Montana concert movie, or Speed Racer, or the I-thought-sure-to-bomb-so-what-do-I-know Beverly Hills Chihuahua, here goes.
Best ( in no particular order):
Cassandra's Dream: Although I love Woody Allen when he is funny, this movie generated actual suspense and drama. Ellen and I looked at each other afterward with slightly surprised expressions and said to each other -- I liked it! Some quibble with the ludicrous set-up of the uncle suggesting the brothers murder someone, but I just went with it. Colin Farrell was excellent.
In Bruges: Violent, but really fun twists and turns, great characters especially (again) Colin Farrell and Ralph Fiennes.
The Hammer: Made my list I guess because it was such an underdog. Featuring "Man Show" and "Loveline" alum Adam Corolla, who I think is funny already. But the movie told a surprisingly simple, hilarious and ultimately touching story of a grown man who decides to get back into the boxing ring. Not rocket science, but a solid funny movie.
The Fall: Simply spectacular to look at. Many faulted the weak story but I thought it worked great, involving me enough to care, all the while showing me amazing places. Apparently there are no effects in this movie. Hard to believe when you see all the crazy beautiful locations.
Bigger Stronger Faster: I love a great fiction film, and I love a great documentary. But I'd rather watch a decent documentary than a decent fiction film any day of the week. Unless of course the decent movie features Marisa Tomei naked. But Bigger Stronger Faster tells a really interesting story of one man's investigation into steroids in sport. He and his brothers all took them at one point. All weightlifters. But what really makes the movie great is the twist it takes halfway through: the filmmaker begins to make a pretty good case for the notion -- what's really wrong with taking steroids? He punctures the commonly held belief that they have been proven harmful. Very interesting. Watch it. (Sad footnote, one of the brothers was just found dead.)
Wall-E: I know, everyone else likes this. And Pixar can go suck it, as far as I'm concerned, given my experience with them at Disney. But luckily that attitude does not keep me from enjoying their movies. I put this one on my list more out of admiration than love. I don't really like the moralizing about fat humans in the second half. But any modern movie where the two protagonists are basically non-verbal, and it's still highly entertaining, is OK in my book.
Man on Wire: The images of this guy wire-walking between the towers of Notre Dame and the Twin Towers are strikingly beautiful. And the movie is surprisingly suspenseful and fun as it tells the story of how they managed to get to the top of the Twin Towers past security, how they managed to string the wire, and how he did it. Of course underneath it all is deep sadness at what the images of those two building now represent. A great movie.
Ghost Town: The funniest movie of the year and effectively emotional to boot. I hate when romantic comedies, or any comedies for that matter, feel they have to turn sweet in order to tell their story. (Here I sincerely apologize for my role in "The Mighty Ducks." Everytime I watch the great "Bad News Bears" I am ashamed.) But in Ghost Town, perhaps the funniest movie of the year, it is done with great care and truthfulness and even a bit of cleverness. (Minor Spoiler: I loved that the woman patient he constantly and carelessly ignored turned out to have her own tragic story. It's so true -- the people we disdain often have much more going on, and deserve much more of our attention, than we assume.) Really well done, I thought it was truly the most entertaining and crowd-pleasing movie of the year, and a shame it didn't find a wider audience. Maybe on DVD.
Synechdoche, NY: My favorite of the year, probably because it reflects, to whatever extent, my worldview. Ellen did not enjoy it. I loved every second of it. An often somber, but wildly inventive and entertainingly absurd look at the essential tragedy of life and the necessity of dealing with our coming deaths. And, even given that previous sentence, it is, more than one would think, funny! Though it was frequently surreal in a Bunuel-ish way, it felt very true to me. A woman buys a house that is literally burning. An obvious metaphor but one I liked -- aren't all our houses burning, sure to consume us eventually? I can't wait to see it again. I know most people will hate it -- but don't fall into the trap of "I didn't get it." Take it on its own terms, "get" what you "get" and don't try so hard to "get" the whole thing. I think you'll enjoy it.
Role Models: Again not a masterpiece, but really really funny. A very simple idea played out beautifully, with some hilarious performances -- especially Paul Rudd, whose odd scrunchy-face every time someone says something that could be construed as dirty made me laugh. But also the bearded guy in the medieval battle game who would only speak in Renaissance English, "Forsooth we must needs to do battle anon" and other ridiculous things like that. I was a little disappointed that it opted for a sort of standard trajectory to a sweet happy ending when I was enjoying its snarkiness so much, but it didn't ruin it for me. I needs must watch it again anon.
Doubt: Loved it. I've seen the play twice, and the reviews have been mixed, so i went with some trepidation. But of course the actors were great, and I thought Shanley found new things in the story to make it feel fresh for the movies. It's really a movie that makes you think and want to talk about it afterwards. As Roger Ebert said, how many movies do that>
Nights in Rodanthe: I never thought a romance like this could make my heart so, but....wait, I didn't see this. I would never see this is a gajillion years. I sped up as I walked past the theaters showing it. If this didn't suck ass, then my worldview is deeply shaken.
Worst (at least of the movies I have seen)
Leatherheads: It sucked, really sucked, but perhaps no more so than any other non-funny comedy. I guess I just thought, what a missed opportunity -- that era of football seems ripe for the plucking, and I think George Ca-loony is funny. But this one made a stench most foul.
Narnia--Prince Caspian: Is it just me or have both these movies set new standards of boring? These kids couldn't be blander, in an "I say Daddy, could I have another drop of tea" British way and the story could not have been more drably photographed. Now normally I'd sit up and take notice of any movie featuring a talking beaver, but this one left me uninterested. If these kids are who I'm supposed to root for in Narnia, then I say bring back the Ice Queen.
Get Smart: I love Steve Carell and thought this would be a no-brainer. Until I saw the trailer, and realized that the movie wasn't funny. It's almost a given that if the trailer isn't funny, the movie isn't funny. Movie marketing execs are shameless for taking the five funniest jokes and putting them in the trailer, often ruining what might have been a mildly funny movie. But in movies like Get Smart, there really are no funny moments. How is this possible?
Tropic Thunder: Almost everyone I know thought this was really funny and a really clever send-up of Hollywood and actors. Not me. In particular, when a fairly realistic movie with a fairly realistic tone has a character for whom we feel some sympathy step on a mine and blow to fleshy bits right before us, I tend to turn off. It was all downhill from there. Did people really think Tom Cruise was funny? What part?
Space Chimps: Well no one involved with this really knows how to make a movie, much less an animated movie, so including them on this list feels a little like booing at the Special Olympics. But it was bad. And ugly.
Towelhead: Just watched this last night on DVD, and we could only get through about twenty minutes. We are Alan Ball fans -- at least we were -- but this movie is way too cartoony and full of less-than-believable characters for its highly challenging subject matter. It's just uncomfortable to watch. Two towels down.
Special Section: Movies I liked that critics didn't
The Happening: I thought it was really suspenseful. If nature's trying to kill you, how do you get away?
Igor: Admittedly, directed by a former co-worker. But I am merciless and wouldn't say I liked it if I didn't. And I did. Clever and funny and great-looking on a shoestring. MUCH better looking than Space Chimps at half the cost. Better than Bolt.
That's all folks. Let me know yours!
Tune in next year for more rapture and rant about the movies!